What’s The Best Nipple Cream For Breastfeeding

And that is a good question. How do you choose the correct one for you. Do you choose a balm, a cream, or a nipple butter. Well, let’s take a look at a few things. You always want to consider ingredients, consistency, taste/smell, portability, and cost to the cream.

When it comes to ingredients, you want to be sure whatever ingredients are in the product you are buying are safe, and most of them are. If you plan on breastfeeding your baby, most of the nipple creams are consistent with organic material which is considered to be safe to both mom and baby. A good way to check is to read the ingredient label on each product you look at. The ingredients are listed in most of these creams below.

Another thing to consider is consistency. Some creams are light in texture and some are even a little heavier and have a waxy feel to it. If you are meticulous in how some creams feel on your skin, then your better off digging more in reading about it. Most creams will thin out through the application process. Just be sure to wash your hands thoroughly before each time it is applied.

Other creams have a smell or taste to them. Its that smell you get when you always first open the top off, and then you become hesitant in using the product ever again. Some individuals would not mind a scent and then some would rather not have a scent to it at all. One thing to consider is that many newborns are sensitive to smell, and you want to make sure that it does not deter your baby from breastfeeding. Most of these listed creams are free of any scents.

In addition, some individuals have looked at portability and its overall bulkiness and size. The creams that are available on the market either come in a jar or tube, but small enough to be taken on-the-go. Many moms always want a light, portable, and easy to use cream, but at the same time you want it to do what it’s supposed to be doing.

Last, but not the least comes the price. Some of these can become more expensive than others, but most creams are generally less than $20 factoring in all the ingredients in each item and its overall purpose.

The nipple creams you are about to see are all based off of the thousands of moms that have used these items, and most of them are given 4 and even 5 stars. So let’s get to it, but first I have listed a few terms that some of you may not be familiar with:

  • Lanolin: A wax secreted by the sebaceous glands of wool-bearing animals.
  • Parabens: A wide array used preservatives.
  • Additives: A substance added to something to improve or preserve it.
  • Preservatives: A substance used to preserve food stuff, wood, or other materials against decay.
  • Petroleum: Fossil fuel matter that has been created by the decomposition of organic material over time.
  • Phthalates: A salt ester of phthalic acid.

Lansinoh Organic Nipple Balm

The Lansinoh Nipple balm is at the top of our list with many 4 and 5 star reviews in the thousands. This organic nipple balm comes in a 2 oz jar which is more than enough to last if applied appropriately. It is considered to be 100% USDA certified organic, and to many moms this is important. The Lansinoh Nipple Balm is an all natural plant based balm. The balm is intended to target tender nipples, dry and sensitive skin, which many moms have to face during breastfeeding period. It is designed to be safe for both mom and baby with no intended smell, taste, or even color. With no additives, preservatives, petroleum, or even parabens; the Lansinoh Organic Nipple Balm is also hypoallergenic. Ingredients include: seed oil, olive fruit oil, beeswax, coconut oil, Shea butter, flower extract, and kernel which all are organic. The balm can be applied to the entire nipple area after each feeding session. It can also be applied during your pregnancy time frame as it can relieve dry and stretching skin.

Medela Tender Care Lanolin Nipple Cream

This Medela Tender Care Lanolin nipple cream does not come in a jar, but rather in a good-size tube for easy application. It comes available in either a 0.3oz or a 2oz tube. It offers all natural soothing care and protection. The Medela Tender Care Cream targets dry, sore, and even tender nipples. The cream is considered to be safe for both mom and baby in which it does not need to be removed before the time of breastfeeding comes. Many moms will say the application is a no-mess process and it is considered to be smooth and gentle on the skin as this can be important when your nipples are sore or tender. The cream consists of all natural ingredients such as: lanolin, coconut/palm oil, and oat beta glucan. This Medela Nipple Cream has been tested and is hypoallergenic.

Motherlove Nipple Cream
Motherlove Nipple Cream is one of the many products within this brand. Even though its original acting purpose is to moisturize dry or cracked nipples, it can even be applied to your hands when dry, and can even be used on your baby when acne erupts. The product even claims to be safe to be used as a lip balm. For moms that are breastfeeding, you do not need to wash it off before a feeding session. Matter of fact, you can apply a layer of it prior to pumping, making those suction cups to be easily removed. The Motherlove Nipple Cream is all natural and is 100% organic consisting of ingredients such as: extra virgin olive oil, beeswax, Shea butter, marshmallow root, and calendula flower. Motherlove nipple cream is lanolin-free and comes packaged in a glass container which might add some weight to it.

Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter

Hence in its name, this organic nipple butter is 100% organic. The Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter is another favorite by many moms. This nipple butter is soothing, buttery, and plant-rich derived. In addition, it’s lanolin-free and non-sticky, which is a feeling many moms do not like. What makes this nipple butter stand out even more is that it’s almost 100% vegan-free, is non-GMO, and contains no petroleum or parabens. Whether you are breastfeeding or pumping, it can be used for moisturizing relief either way. Earth Mama Organic nipple butter has been dermatologist and clinically tested for skin irritation. This product can be used in other areas of the body and includes: the cheeks, lips, cuticles, elbows, and on the heels. Some ingredients include beeswax, cocoa, seed butter, Shea, mango and flower extract. Majority of the customers that have used this product were highly satisfied.

Bamboobies Organic Nipple Balm

The Bamboobies Organic Nipple Balm comes in a small container but effective for use. It provides a soothing relief for those newly used painful and cracked nipples. It is 100% USDA organic and toxic-free. This organic nipple balm is made with simple and natural ingredients such as: extra virgin olive oil, beeswax, and Shea butter. It is lanolin-free with no additional parabens, phthalates, or any synthetic fragrances eliminating that smell every time you open. You can apply this nipple balm to your nipples after you nurse, during your pumping session, or as needed. Do keep in mind that the olive oil ingredient can stain your clothing, so just make sure you provide a barrier during each time you use it. Another thing to remember is to have this item stored right side up at room temperature or cooler just so the ingredients do not become separated. Some key ingredients include extra virgin olive oil, beeswax, Shea butter, and calendula flower.

The Honest Company Organic All-Purpose Balm

This Honest Company Organic All-purpose balm is one of its kind. It gives you all the relief that you need making breastfeeding more comfortable. It is organic, unscented, hypoallergenic, and even dermatologist tested. The all-purpose balm is rich in its organic ingredients making it safe for you and your baby as well. Ingredients include Shea butter, coconut oil, aloe, and jojoba. It does not include petrolatum, lanolin, silicones, phthalates, synthetic fragrances, or PEG’s. Besides using it on your nipples, you can use it in other areas of the body where needed. The Honest Company Balm comes in the shape of a tube for you to take on-the-go. As it shows it on the front of the tube, ‘Calm Your Nip Balm’.

Bella B Nurturing Nipple Butter

Bella B Nipple Butter is liked by many breastfeeding moms as it can work wonders on dry, cracked, and bleeding nipples. This nipple butter uses plant based ingredients that are safe for both mom and baby. Cocoa and Shea butter are combined to provide excellent healing effects. Without using any animal products, you can use this before and after each time you breastfeed. While the cream may feel thick as it comes out from the tube, it will start to melt and thin away as you rub away. The nipple butter is free of petroleum and parabens.

E.Ra Organics Mommy Balm

The E. Ra Organics Mommy Balm has plenty of 5 star review from moms to have been completely satisfied. With its USDA certified organic ingredients, it can take the pain and irritation away from breastfeeding sessions. It can soothe, hydrate cracked areas, and prevent chafing in the most frequent used areas. It includes vitamin-rich, anti-inflammatory ingredients that can be used on sensitive and damaged skin surfaces anywhere on the body. This balm excludes parabens, alcohol, lanolin, scented perfumes, and petroleum. Just use a small amount of this balm and spread it evenly across the affected area without having to worry staining your clothes. Just be sure to keep this jar in a dry room temperature space so it does not become hard over time.

Palmers Cocoa Butter Nursing Cream

Palmers Cocoa Butter Nursing Cream does not get recognized as much, but has plenty of moms that use it. The nursing cream comes in a good-size tube to soothe sore cracked nipples that many moms experience during breastfeeding. Its free of parabens and phthalates, which many moms tend to deter when they see these ingredients. Instead, it comes with cocoa butter, petroleum, and pro-vitamin B5 which will help in sore cracked nipples, moisturizing and conditioning affected areas. Some moms have applied it before their baby has arrived and used as a preventative measure. To be on the safe side, it has been dermatologist approved.

Milkies Nipple Nurture Balm

This balm comes in a 1.5 oz container which will typically last you for about a month if applied appropriately. The main purpose of this cream is to soothe, protect, heal the affected areas, and even prevent soreness and cracking from re-appearing. You can kiss the discomfort that comes with breastfeeding goodbye. The recommended use is to apply the entire area of the nipple after each time your baby feeds. The Milkies Nipple Nurture Balm is made from organic ingredients making it safe for both mom and baby. It does not include lanolin, additives, animal products, artificial colors, preservatives, or any other toxic chemicals. Lactation specialists do recommended this balm.


The main takeaway from all of this is to purchase a cream that you and your baby will be comfortable using. The price is not so much of a difference or an issue, but primarily its overall purpose and leverage. Hope you had made your decision wise in picking one out in having it ready by your side.

I hope you enjoyed reading this article, and please feel free to let me know if you have any comments, questions, or concerns.

22 thoughts on “What’s The Best Nipple Cream For Breastfeeding”

  1. Great information. I am going to pass this to my daughter. She just gave us our first grand baby 🙂 I know she will find this very interesting. She loves to read about tips for new parents.

  2. I have two kids, but I had no idea there are so many different kinds of nipple creams. I remember I used one, but I can’t remember which one.
    This is a very detailed post and I enjoyed reading it. I especially loved that you explained common terms that are often used, but a lot times people don’t know what it is. Educating people is so important! Thank you for sharing this valuable information.

  3. Thank you so much for this highly informative article! I have so many friends (all of whom are expecting, 1st time mothers) wondering about creams to make the breastfeeding process as smooth and painless as possible. You offered creams that I hadn’t even heard of before, but that would be perfect for them! If I ever decide to have children, I’ll definitely refer to this article as well! I am going to share this post with my friends and family. God bless you, and keep up the good work!

  4. Yes, of course, every mother who breastfeeds a child in the first place thinks about the safety of the ingredients in a product. And there are many. You’ve presented them in details. Great article! Thanks for sharing

  5. I also have two kids, I used Medela purelan as recommended by my friends. Never knew there are so many different ingredients for nipple cream.
    Thank you very much for your detailed information. It is very helpful for first time parents. I wish this website was already there when I had my first baby almost 10 years ago!

  6. When I gave birth I had a really big problem with nipples, the only cream that worked best for me was Medela Tender Care Lanolin Nipple Cream. But i didn’t really pay any attention on ingredients Thank you for your info, all keep it in mind next time I have any nipple problems.

  7. Thank you for this article. I will share it with my friend who was looking for a nipple cream and couldn’t decide which to buy



Leave a Comment